The Scottish Alliance for People and Places

The Scottish Alliance for People and Places

  • Menu
  • Account
  • Home
  • ABOUT
  • NEWS & VIEWS
  • OUR MEMBERS
  • CONTACT US
LET’S GET SOCIAL
Contact Us
  • 00126788899
  • [email protected]
  • Member Login

It’s an emotive thing, drawing lines on maps

  • Home
  • NEWS & VIEWS
  • Featured
  • It’s an emotive thing, drawing lines on maps
Featured

It’s an emotive thing, drawing lines on maps

Sam Tedcastle, Senior Practitioner at the Centre for Good Relations, discusses the role of civic mediation in planning.

It’s a simple thing to draw a line on a map, but that line means different things to different people. A line could be a border between communities, a new road in front of your house or the first sign of a new shopping centre. It signifies that something is about to change.

Change affects people differently and causes them to behave in different ways. How planners manage this change is key.

One of the challenges for planning is bringing different perspectives together and finding a way forward that best suits the needs of a community.

For a planning authority, change is about looking forward and building a resilient future creating stronger, safer, more economically and environmentally sustainable places for people.

For a developer, change can be a vision, a livelihood, an opportunity to breathe life into a place, an opportunity to prosper.

For a community, change can be for better or worse, it often means letting go of something from the past to make space for something new. It can mean new people moving in, different ways of travelling, new places to go to school or to work. It could feel like there is no longer space for you.

We often come across situations where communities feel the planning process does not hear them or their needs, or where a developer is frustrated with the ‘lack of vision’ of parts of a community that result in tensions escalating.

How can civic mediation support planning?

At the Centre for Good Relations we’ve used the process of civic mediation in a range of planning contexts, most often when things have gone badly wrong and conflict has developed.

We have applied it to:

  • Housing Market Renewal
  • Building Schools for the Future
  • Infrastructure projects
  • Marine planning (watch a film we made on a fisheries mediation project)
  • Development of places for worship
  • Placement of Gypsy traveller sites

In each of the scenarios above, the community had become disengaged or the relationships with decision makers had broken down; one could no longer understand the other and communication had become a challenge. We used civic meditation to develop a shared understanding of the issues, improve relationships and to facilitate arrangements to move forward.

When to mediate or When to start mediation?

It’s always best to be brought in early so that strong foundations for dialogue are carefully built and negative impacts can be kept to a minimum saving both time and money.

In our experience relationships have broken down when communities haven’t had the time, space or opportunity to think about these developments in a positive way and this is exacerbated when there is already a high level of mistrust for the planning authority or developers.

A brief background to civic mediation

Civic mediation focuses on the human dimensions of a situation (feelings, emotions etc) and aims not only to transform conflicts but also to restore, renew or adjust the relationships to support effective problem solving.

It is an iterative process and no two situations are the same. We always tailor a mediation process to the situation.

A number of functions of mediation can support the planning process to:

  • assist communication
  • improve understandings
  • support creative thinking
  • explore accommodations
  • facilitate agreements

If you would like to know more or want to discuss a project get in touch –  contact [email protected].

755 Views

December 8, 2017

Sam Tedcastle, Senior Practitioner at the Centre for Good Relations, discusses the role of civic mediation in planning.

It’s a simple thing to draw a line on a map, but that line means different things to different people. A line could be a border between communities, a new road in front of your house or the first sign of a new shopping centre. It signifies that something is about to change.

Change affects people differently and causes them to behave in different ways. How planners manage this change is key.

One of the challenges for planning is bringing different perspectives together and finding a way forward that best suits the needs of a community.

For a planning authority, change is about looking forward and building a resilient future creating stronger, safer, more economically and environmentally sustainable places for people.

For a developer, change can be a vision, a livelihood, an opportunity to breathe life into a place, an opportunity to prosper.

For a community, change can be for better or worse, it often means letting go of something from the past to make space for something new. It can mean new people moving in, different ways of travelling, new places to go to school or to work. It could feel like there is no longer space for you.

We often come across situations where communities feel the planning process does not hear them or their needs, or where a developer is frustrated with the ‘lack of vision’ of parts of a community that result in tensions escalating.

How can civic mediation support planning?

At the Centre for Good Relations we’ve used the process of civic mediation in a range of planning contexts, most often when things have gone badly wrong and conflict has developed.

We have applied it to:

  • Housing Market Renewal
  • Building Schools for the Future
  • Infrastructure projects
  • Marine planning (watch a film we made on a fisheries mediation project)
  • Development of places for worship
  • Placement of Gypsy traveller sites

In each of the scenarios above, the community had become disengaged or the relationships with decision makers had broken down; one could no longer understand the other and communication had become a challenge. We used civic meditation to develop a shared understanding of the issues, improve relationships and to facilitate arrangements to move forward.

When to mediate or When to start mediation?

It’s always best to be brought in early so that strong foundations for dialogue are carefully built and negative impacts can be kept to a minimum saving both time and money.

In our experience relationships have broken down when communities haven’t had the time, space or opportunity to think about these developments in a positive way and this is exacerbated when there is already a high level of mistrust for the planning authority or developers.

A brief background to civic mediation

Civic mediation focuses on the human dimensions of a situation (feelings, emotions etc) and aims not only to transform conflicts but also to restore, renew or adjust the relationships to support effective problem solving.

It is an iterative process and no two situations are the same. We always tailor a mediation process to the situation.

A number of functions of mediation can support the planning process to:

  • assist communication
  • improve understandings
  • support creative thinking
  • explore accommodations
  • facilitate agreements

If you would like to know more or want to discuss a project get in touch –  contact [email protected].

McLeish: Planning Bill’s a good start, but there is space to build on the ambition
The Positives of Mediation in Planning

Information

  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • OUR MEMBERS
  • NEWS & VIEWS
  • CONTACT US

Contact Us

  • The Scottish Alliance for People and Places c/o PAS 3rd floor, 125 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 4AD
  • 0131 220 9730
  • [email protected]
  • www.peopleandplaces.scot

Site Policies

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy (UK)

© The Scottish Alliance for People and Places

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}